Tuesday, January 21, 2003
RIAA Wins Battle to ID Kazaa User
"A federal judge orders Verizon to disclose the identity of an alleged P2P pirate in a decision that could make it easier for the music industry to crack down on file-swapping networks....
The dispute is not about whether the RIAA will be able to force Verizon to reveal the identity of a suspected copyright infringer, but about what legal mechanism copyright holders will be able to use. The RIAA would prefer to rely on the DMCA's turbocharged-subpoena process because it is cheaper and faster than other methods--but Verizon and civil liberties groups have said it is not sufficiently privacy-protective.
At issue in the RIAA's request is an obscure part of the DMCA that permits a copyright owner to send a subpoena ordering a "service provider" to turn over information about a subscriber. Verizon says the DMCA does not apply because the company is only a conduit and is not hosting the material on its servers." [CNET News.com]
This is where I rely completely on blawgs to dissect this, but this message sent to the DMCA-Discuss mailing list is disturbing:
"The DMCA (Section 512) has a number of ugly provisions, including the infamous 'takedown' provision. Included in those provisions are an expedited subpoena process where a copyright holder can go to a court clerk and demand from an ISP the name of a subscriber alleged to have violated copyrights -- all this before any determination of whether a violation has occurred has been done. The RIAA did this to a Verizon subscriber. However, Verizon fought back by claiming the copyrighted information was not on Verizon's network -- it was on the subscriber's own network, and Verizon merely provided access to it and therefore fell under the exemptions of section 512(a), which has neither subpoena nor 'takedown' provisions.
The judge today ruled for RIAA against Verizon. This means that the RIAA can demand an ISP take down information stored on its customer's computers, AND can demand the names of those customers without even going through the trouble of filing a lawsuit.
Even when the law is on our side, we lose."